Shooting Seismic Does not Kill Fish

“Sound waves from seismic data acquisition resulted in increased catches for some species and smaller catches for others.” To me, that sounds a bit inconclusive, but it is still the main result from research done on an important fishing ground and a frontier exploration province offshore Norway during the summer of 2009.
This article appeared in Vol. 7, No. 2 - 2010


Net catches of Greenland halibut (Reinhardtius hippoglossoides), a deepwater fish found between 200 and 1600 m in waters with temperatures from 1-4 °C, were higher during and after seismic operations than they were before them. Line catches of Greenland halibut, however, declined during seismic work, but increased afterwards. After having acquired seismic offshore Norway for almost 50 years (the very first survey was shot in 1962, in Skagerrak), including major 2D surveys and huge 3D lay outs, a large research programme was conducted last year aimed at improving the understanding of how seismic campaigns affect fish distribution and the commercial fisheries.

The research programme was undertaken in conjunction with the acquisition of a 3D survey within the highly prospective Nordland VII (Vesterålen) area north of the Arctic Circle. The acquisition overlapped some of the best traditional offshore fishing grounds in Norway.

The Institute of Marine Research was given responsibility for carrying out the project, which was financed by the Norwegian Petroleum Directorate (NPD). According to NPD, it is one of the largest such research projects ever conducted.

The project revealed that the sound of the air-guns affected the fisheries in the study area off Vesterålen “in a number of ways”. These “ways” included both increased and reduced catches of individual fish species, made by different types of gear, and the fact that some species withdrew from the area, while others remained.

The details we leave to those who are particularly interested. The overall conclusion, however, is that the research programme failed to prove that seismic acquisition has a devastating effect on fish and fishing, contrary to statements often made by fishermen, and their allies in “environmentally friendly” organizations, whose main goal is to make oil and gas exploration more difficult. It is in fact no secret that the reason why Norwegian fishermen make a lot of noise (!) about seismic acquisition is to get compensation for reduced catchments.

The outcome of the USD 4 million research programme will not change this. Certainly not. Even though the conclusions are not accepted by the fishermen. First, they ask for research, and when the results are not in their favour, they are not willing to face the truth.


Related Articles

Editorials North America

Concerned About the Environment

Syncrude, the Canadian energy giant that is producing some 350,000bopd from the oil sands in Alberta, has been charged with the deaths of nearly 500 ducks in a massive, toxic settling pond in April 2008. Pictures of sludge-covered birds garnered international attention. The operator highly regrets the incident and says "we feel horrible this occurred and there's a huge resolve in our organization since then to implement the appropriate changes to help prevent it from happening again."
Editorial464 thumb

Editorials Worldwide


In my previous ‘Editor’s Patch’ on communicating the science and technology of our industry I concentrated on 'What' and 'Why' we should be communicating. I want to now take a look at 'How' 'and the many methods at our disposal.
Thumb 1130x450 thumb